Progressive death metal is a music genre that merges progressive metal and death metal. The violent, extreme elements from death metal is combined with the intricacy and dynamics from progressive music.
This article is a part of my full guide to death metal music.
What makes a band progressive death metal?
There is a wide array of bands considered progressive death metal. The genre includes everything from ultra-technical, extreme bands like Necrophagist, Decrepit Birth and Lykathea Aflame to more progressive contemporaries like Opeth and Cynic.
The borders between progressive and technical death metal can be hard to distinguish; many bands rightfully belong in both categories. Many of these progressive bands naturally also employ some non-metal elements like synths, acoustic guitars and clean vocals.
Some recognizable (but not not mandatory) progressive death metal traits are:
- Chaotic song structures
- Strange time signatures
- Unusual harmony and melody
- Mashing the death metal style up with widely different music genres like progressive rock, jazz and classical music
Genre evolution from old school death metal
Death metal itself started in the mid-80’s when bands like Death and Possessed wanted to take the extreme sounds of thrash metal even further. The early death metal sound was purposely ferocious and as violent as possible. The sound from the 80’s and early 90’s scenes in the U.S. and Sweden is now referred to as old school death metal.
In the late 80’s, some heavy metal and thrash metal bands (including giants Metallica and Iron Maiden) started experimenting with longer songs and progressive ideas. It didn’t take long before this spread to extreme metal as well.
The start of progressive death metal
Progressive death metal started in the early 90’s when bands like Death, Cynic and Atheist started getting creative with their death metal sounds. There was a strong jazz influence and the compositions were often action-packed, abrupt and adventurous.
In 1991, Death released the jazzy, spacy “Human” album, featuring Cynic members Sean Reinert and Paul Masvidal. For me, “Human” is probably the ultimate album in the style, combining the jazz elements with aggressive, dynamic death metal. It’s a very flashy, technical album, complete with the catchy songwriting that made Death great it in the first place.
There is no doubt that the inclusion of Reinert and Masvidal brought some of the indulgent experimentation from Cynic into the Death sound. Cynic took their time, but released their highly praised debut album “Focus” in 1993.
Cynic disappeared, but returned as a more rock-oriented progressive band with 2008’s “Traced in Air”. Being the weirdo that I am, I actually prefer “Traced in Air” to “Focus”. But don’t tell anyone, it just gets awkward.
Another important early band was Atheist. Atheist released three adventurous jazz/death metal classics in 1989, 1991 and 1993. The band pretty much achieved the same thing Death did with “Human”; a successful combination of jazzy, rhythmical complexity and death metal aggression.
Several other old school bands like Pestilence from the Netherlands and Canada’s Gorguts joined in on the complexity party later on.
Swedish death metal scene joining in
The Swedish death metal scene also started utilizing progressive metal elements in the early 90’s. Edge of Sanity mastermind Dan Swanö used some clean vocals, even on the band’s debut album. Later the band became full-fledged progressive death metal.
Another strange, progressive gem from the early Swedish scene is the completely manic 1992 album “Prodigal Sun” by Afflicted. Opeth also got active in the mid-90’s. However, they didn’t become fully relevant for the progressive death metal yet.
Evolution of American progressive death metal
Backing up to the mid-90’s and changing continent, Death kept going more and more progressive, technical and melodic. 1993’s “Individual Thought Patterns” was another exercise in intricate, yet well written death metal. The “Symbolic” album (1995) saw Death’s sound grow more contemporary and melodic.
Death’s last album before Chuck Schuldiner’s unfortunate demise was 1998’s “The Sound of Perseverance”. This release can be described as a pure progressive metal album. The songs are extremely adventurous, filled with sprees of skillful lead guitar, propelled by an insane rhythm section consisting of Richard Christy and Scott Clendenin.
Action on the other continent
During the 90’s, other new twists and turns to the death metal music style happened around the world. Amorphis released its famous “Tales From the Thousand Lakes” album in 1994. This album is a merciless mash-up of musical styles, incorporating everything from folk metal to progressive rock and doom metal into a melodic death metal soundscape.
Edge of Sanity went progressive and wild on 1996’s “Crimson”, a 40 minute one song album. Opeth released two quality albums in “My Arms, Your Hearse” (1998) and “Still Life” (1999), expanding on their combination of death metal and progressive rock. Katatonia released their classic death/doom album “Brave Murder Day”, a one of a kind disc that certainly could be described as having prog overtones.
Early 2000’s – from Opeth to the technical death metal boom
The genre enjoyed a wide boost in popularity in 2001 when Opeth released their hailed “Blackwater Park” album. It propelled the progressive death metal genre big time, and turned many young melodic death metal fans like myself onto more adventurous types of extreme music.
Ultra-technical Germans Necrophagist also released their two full-length albums “Onset of Putrefaction” (1999) and “Epitaph” (2004) during this time period. This was the start of a technical death metal boom that’s still somewhat ongoing today. For a while in my youth it felt like everyone in extreme metal was just trying to play as many notes per second as possible. It winded down, but the factor, good or bad, is still there sometimes.
The inclusion of classical music was something new and something that influenced upcoming techdeath bands like Spawn of Possession and Fleshgod Apocalypse. Technical death metal has gone gigantic. The subgenre stagnated pretty fast in a creative sense, but there is an extreme amounts of bands playing it.
Other newer progressive death metal stylings
Gojira, one of the most popular modern extreme metal bands, is also usually counted as progdeath. I’m not a fan of the band, but I understand why they are categorized as progressive. The band is certainly not afraid to experiment, but I’m not sure that they belong in the death metal genre to begin with.
There are also progressive leanings in many melodic death metal bands. Australia’s Be’lakor tend to write songs that are a bit longer and adventurous than the average bands in that genre and often count as progressive. Sweden’s In Mourning is another rather contemporary extreme metal band experimenting with progressive ideas.
Dan Swanö’s “Moontower” from 1998 is also a pretty unique album mixing progressive music and death metal. Swanö goes crazy with 80’s keyboard, creating a wonderful mash-up between Rush-influenced music and death metal.
He also released Edge of Sanity’s “Crimson II” in 2003, another great exercise in a similar music style. It’s not as lush and polished as “Moontower”, but it also has a massive keyboard presence.
I hope this article taught you enjoy about the genre to get started. Let’s finish it off with some essential progressive death metal albums.
Atheist – Piece of Time (1989)
Death – Human (1991)
Amorphis – Tales from the Thousand Lakes (1994)
Dan Swanö – Moontower (1998)
Opeth – Blackwater Park (2001)
I hope this guide helped you learn what progressive death metal is all about and what bands and albums to start out with. There is so much good music in this genre, so please drop a line in the comment section if I’m missing out on something awesome. Personally, I’m not that into the super-technical side of things, but there are exceptions!
Also, my band Soliloquium plays a progressive take on death/doom metal that you might like if you enjoy the music style. Please head over to our Bandcamp page by clicking on the text or the big image link below. Your support would be greatly appreciated! Thank you so much for reading my article!